I'm putting myself in with the small group that enjoyed ATYCLB. These days, it's rarely the one I grab if I want to put some U2 on, but I sure as hell wore out my copy when it came out. I even consider Wild Honey and IALW two of the better tunes on it, though they were not the ones that immediately caught my attention upon initial listens. However, I will say Walk On, which I DID enjoy initially, is difficult to listen to now as I'm pretty sick of it. I'd be fine with never hearing that live again.
That being said, I love Pop though. It was the first U2 album I purchased. I think its hard to compare the two though because they are so contrasting so I'm not going to say which one is better because I don't think I possibly can. They are two completely different things, aside from both being U2 albums.
I am also one that considers 1980s my decade of choice for U2 music, which I think is also a minority group here.