0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
I found the original Mercy to be somewhere between mediocre and average, and the new one to be pretty good. I realise this puts me in a minority. The old one was way too padded, didn't sound at all finished and had those cringeworthy bridges which have thankfully been removed from the newer. (Sorry, but "You wanted violins and you got Nero" just reeks of Bono desperately trying to be clever and failing horribly)
As long as Bono doesn't release a Chocolate Chrome Mercy, Vanilla is all good.You're silence, searching for a sound, Your heart is aching... love that part, particularly the emotion in Bono's voice.
No matter what form it is in, Mercy is an awkward mix of poor lyrics beside great lyrics. Much as I think the new one is far superior to the padded old one, it's hard to claim that "You wanna kill me and I wanna die" is a masterwork.
https://twitter.com/u2tours/status/298503688857722881
Quote from: The Unknown Caller on February 04, 2013, 01:27:22 PMNo matter what form it is in, Mercy is an awkward mix of poor lyrics beside great lyrics. Much as I think the new one is far superior to the padded old one, it's hard to claim that "You wanna kill me and I wanna die" is a masterwork.As is "Because because because we can we must."
Quote from: Midnight is Where the Day Begins on February 04, 2013, 02:09:54 PMQuote from: The Unknown Caller on February 04, 2013, 01:27:22 PMNo matter what form it is in, Mercy is an awkward mix of poor lyrics beside great lyrics. Much as I think the new one is far superior to the padded old one, it's hard to claim that "You wanna kill me and I wanna die" is a masterwork.As is "Because because because we can we must."Definitely, although I give it a small pass not for being anything other than a bleh lyric but because it's a musically nice part of the song, particularly live. Needs tweaking though.The WAIE edited version > The live 2010 version > the 2004 version. So hopefully on this path, the 2013 album version will be the best of all!
Quote from: The Unknown Caller on January 31, 2013, 08:33:55 AMI found the original Mercy to be somewhere between mediocre and average, and the new one to be pretty good. I realise this puts me in a minority. The old one was way too padded, didn't sound at all finished and had those cringeworthy bridges which have thankfully been removed from the newer. (Sorry, but "You wanted violins and you got Nero" just reeks of Bono desperately trying to be clever and failing horribly) Not quite as bad as "we're a binary code, a one and a zero". Well...duh. Captain obvious , Bono.