Same here. I am very critical but have a weak spot for that song. Still not sure why and I've been trying to figure that out for 2 years now.
If loving SFS is wrong, then I don't want to be right.
It was probably my least favorite off SOI and still ranks towards the bottom, but it admittedly grew on me a bit after seeing a few of the shows in 2015.
Rock n roll isn't like a broadway musical or opera for me - perfect singing or playing is not a necessity at all
Or doing nothing but ambient tracks or avoiding pop hooks solely in the name of hipster street cred... for me anyway.