If the band does it, I hope it's all four and not just Bono & Edge. The clip with Red Hot Chili Peppers was great, and the one with just Chris Martin stunk.
Agreed. And I also hope that all four band members actually participate in the skit--not just Bono and Edge. I feel Adam and Larry have the potential to be the highlights of the skit.
I was recently watching one of the Carpool Karaoke skits and thought "I wonder if U2 would ever do this?" I quickly dismissed it because (a) I did not think James would be a fan of theirs (seems like a lot of British celebrities LOATHE U2/Coldplay/other big bands and (b) I did not think he'd be able to land a band as legendary as U2 (the only ones bigger to land would be the Rolling Stones and the remaining Beatles). It's surprising to hear that James is actually a big fan of theirs and that the band apparently are considering doing it.
Previously, James has sometimes dressed up as whoever he was doing karaoke with. For instance, when he did karaoke with Britney Spears, he wore a school girl outfit (ala her "Oops" video) and when he did karaoke with the Chili Peppers, he went nude (ala their old concerts where they were naked or close to it). I think it might be funny if James dressed up as Macphisto or another of the alter egos. At the very least, I'd expect him to show up dressed like Bono (leather jacket, glasses) but it'd be funny to see him go a step further with that.