@U2 Forum

U2 => Tours => Topic started by: u2and on September 10, 2009, 07:01:03 AM

Title: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: u2and on September 10, 2009, 07:01:03 AM
I'm in favour of edgier set lists from U2 when they play live. The crowd pleaser may please the crowd but the crowd need to be challenged too.

Which of the usual 'classics' would you like to see dropped?
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: U2alwaysforever on September 10, 2009, 08:04:02 AM
Pride is a great song, but long overdue for a vacation.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: DGordon1 on September 10, 2009, 08:23:36 AM
Pride and One stand out immediately. Streets gets a bye because it's Streets, and SBS always rocks. I personally think COBL should be played more sparingly; it's a good song but not worthy of being in every show imo. Especially since it was in every show in the last tour.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: The Unknown Caller on September 10, 2009, 10:00:04 AM
None of the above- I think every one of them should be kept. :)
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: Achtung_Habs on September 10, 2009, 10:02:03 AM
Seriously, who even thought about dropping Streets, don't tell me the show would be better with Streets out of the setlist, it would actually be a major hole in the set.  Like an interrupted climax.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: satellitedog01 on September 10, 2009, 01:10:28 PM
Well I'd ditch SBS, Pride, WOWY and NYD too... I voted SBS, they've written better pacifist songs.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: Midnight is Where the Day Begins on September 10, 2009, 01:18:54 PM
WOWY, then move up MOS and end with Drowning Man.  ;)
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: silvrlvr on September 10, 2009, 01:30:39 PM
Never drop Streets, but jeez, give the others a rest. This isn't a PBS special. It's a gig for people who avidly follow the band and some newbies. You don't have to reintroduce yourselves each night.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: pizzaclub on September 10, 2009, 01:32:24 PM
I'm gonna go with Unforgettable Fire.  I know it wasn't played for a while before this tour, but that song has not aged well.  I'm actually kind of not really looking forward to it.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: markreed on September 10, 2009, 01:35:36 PM
eat humble pie. I say rotate out Pride, SBS, WOWY, Still Haven't Found, and play 1 or 2 of those 4 instead of 4 out of 4 every night.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: ayajedi on September 10, 2009, 01:44:59 PM
Drop With or Without You.....I never thought I'd say that!
Bono sounds tired of singing it and I did not like how the band played it at Wembley in August.
Give WOWY a rest.
They should not drop Streets because it is one of the highlights of the live show
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: Midnight is Where the Day Begins on September 10, 2009, 01:48:48 PM
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
Drop With or Without You.....I never thought I'd say that!
Bono sounds tired of singing it and I did not like how the band played it at Wembley in August.
Give WOWY a rest.
They should not drop Streets because it is one of the highlights of the live show

Yes and move MOS up, then Drowning Man!!  ;)
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: The Unknown Caller on September 10, 2009, 01:53:14 PM
Ugh. I have no problem with Drowning Man, but I think it's be a dreadful closer, whereas MoS was MADE to be a closer...
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: Midnight is Where the Day Begins on September 10, 2009, 02:01:30 PM
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
Ugh. I have no problem with Drowning Man, but I think it's be a dreadful closer, whereas MoS was MADE to be a closer...

I only said that because they said they don't like playing DM so early for the mood it makes.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: LToy on September 10, 2009, 02:27:28 PM
Wish I could vote for more than 1 song from this list for the poll
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: ken on September 10, 2009, 02:33:03 PM
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
Never drop Streets, but jeez, give the others a rest. This isn't a PBS special. It's a gig for people who avidly follow the band and some newbies. You don't have to reintroduce yourselves each night.

Disagree.  

In a 70,000 capacity stadium tour, I suspect the majority of the audience is made up of casual fans, by which I mean people who, yes are solid fans, but are not 'avidly' so, to use your word.  Many will have some albums, perhaps been to a concert or two in the past, are aquainted with the well known songs, which they may remember from 80's and 90's college parties, but they don't frequent fan forums discussing the relative merits of the tracklists of Zooropa and ATYCLB.  People who avidly follow the band, although a very large number in absolute terms, are likely to be in the minority.

Hence the well known tracks have to be included, to give the majority of causual fans (and a sizeable proportion of the minority of avid fans) what they want: an evening of classic U2, together with some new material.

Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: evilways811 on September 10, 2009, 04:21:18 PM
Out of those? none.

My write in vote goes to, "Stuck in a Moment.." and "In a Little While". Also if possible switch "Elevation" with "The Fly".
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: aurabender on September 10, 2009, 05:13:39 PM
this poll seemed a bit biased. Nothing form NLOTH to chose from?
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: JoshuaTree94 on September 10, 2009, 05:52:09 PM
I voted for With Or Without You. That is a classic and I love it, but out of the list, I'd rather hear Pride.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: briscoetheque on September 10, 2009, 06:27:27 PM
Keep these setlist threads comin...

We need more.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: Vervefloyd on September 10, 2009, 07:08:33 PM
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
Never drop Streets, but jeez, give the others a rest. This isn't a PBS special. It's a gig for people who avidly follow the band and some newbies. You don't have to reintroduce yourselves each night.

Disagree.  

In a 70,000 capacity stadium tour, I suspect the majority of the audience is made up of casual fans, by which I mean people who, yes are solid fans, but are not 'avidly' so, to use your word.  Many will have some albums, perhaps been to a concert or two in the past, are aquainted with the well known songs, which they may remember from 80's and 90's college parties, but they don't frequent fan forums discussing the relative merits of the tracklists of Zooropa and ATYCLB.  People who avidly follow the band, although a very large number in absolute terms, are likely to be in the minority.

Hence the well known tracks have to be included, to give the majority of causual fans (and a sizeable proportion of the minority of avid fans) what they want: an evening of classic U2, together with some new material.



I disagree with your disagreement.  no song should ever be played to death and I include streets in this.  The "classics" sound dreadfully tired and whats funny is U2 has so many hits yet they keep the same core of them every night which just by very human nature means U2 will get bored and tired with them and go through the numbers.  its unavoidable.  70,000 screaming fans can't make the song more enjoyable to play every single night.  when you're bored your bored.  this isnt a broadway show where a song has to be there because their is an exact script that has to be followed for the plot.  and broadway casts change so its new people doing those songs and performances so they are less tired.  I'm actually skipping the tour based on the performances I have heard and cause U2 has decided to act like the only thing about technology is about building a big stage.  when in fact technology is in this day and age about immediate information where everyone can get a set list in real time.  even casual fans can find them immediately.  rotating songs 6 and 8 and using the same songs is not rotation.

so i say dump them all and take a huge risk.  how about playing 50-60 songs and acknowledging their are 2 albums before War, one after Zooropa and that something can be played off Zooropa other than acoustically.  cause U2 is missing a very interesting concept.  by playing essentially just the new album and the hits, they are not exposing the casual fans to the rest of their catalog.  What if they play Gone and some casual fans say damn that was great and ask someone next to them what album that was from and they say Pop.  and the casual fan responds hey i'm gonna go check that album out i thought it was all techno.  on most nights U2 ignores 5 albums.  look at the last 10-15 shows, with the exception of stay no songs from boy, october, rattle and hum, zooropa or pop.  thats 5/12 of their albums.  U2 can still do their hits and represent their whole catalog and maybe open more people up instead of just trying to please them.  concerts are not all about sing-a-longs and hits.  they require give and take.  but these U2 shows lately are just too audience friendly.  and i'm sure someone will respond with saying well TUF and UV are back for the diehards.  maybe i'm wrong but the diehards want nightly change.  TUF and UV are old hat.  they are regulars now.  U2 can cater to everyone just as Springsteen, REM and Radiohead do.  Those 3 bands rotate a good portion of their set every night.

and sure U2 has the right to choose whatever they want to play.  but come one who in the band is the one standing up and shooting down urges.  they had an urge to play drowning man and somehow decided it didnt fit and was too emotional to be followed with a song.  thats a load of bs.  just play it.  what made them practice If God Will Send His Angels that one day at sound check.  guess what they had an urge, but again shot down in front of a live crowd.  they rehearsed I will follow, but didnt act on it.  its impossible that U2 only gets urges to play songs like Elevation, NYD, UTEOTW, etc - the regulars every tour.  they have so many songs and Edge ran his mouth on how everything was fair game.  I feel like the rep from the crowd of the Obama speech "you lie."  you can keep a concept and rotate a set with the new songs as the core.

in the end, and people are gonna rip me for this, but maybe U2 just aren't that good at playing their songs.  and what I mean by that is U2 can't just play a song (party girl is about the only exception) without endless rehearsing.  Please in Baltimore in 2001 was a perfect example I was there and they butchered it.  Electrical Storm never quite sounded right this tour.  so they fall back on the same ones from every tour.  they bring back a couple of older tunes but they practice them a lot before playing them. 

so i take back what i said.  U2 should leave them all in cause the show might be a train wreck without them.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: JoshuaTree94 on September 10, 2009, 08:30:51 PM
Okay, so the diehards want nightly change. Maybe these diehards feel a need to go to every single show. That's fine. But a very large number of people in the crowd aren't worrying about the setlist from show four on the tour and are worried about how similar it will be to their show, number twenty-four. A lot of those people can only see one, maybe two, shows a tour. So if they're going to be pleased with their show, does playing Boy/Girl, Street Missions, Big Girls are Best, and 4th of July really sound very appealing? Yes, Streets, Pride, New Year's Day, With or Without You, and so on get played all the time. Not surprising at all. But would you give a crappy night to the rest of the 80,000 folks in the audience, who have waited maybe their whole life to hear the drums of Sunday Bloody Sunday or the ringing guitar of Pride, just to hear the obscurities that will only please you?

And it's a concert. People who are fans of U2 are going to go to the concert. Of course it's fan-friendly! The performers want to give their fans a good time, in the best way that they feel they can do it. If it means playing Streets every night, that is fine by me.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: u2and on September 11, 2009, 02:21:58 AM
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
Seriously, who even thought about dropping Streets, don't tell me the show would be better with Streets out of the setlist, it would actually be a major hole in the set.  Like an interrupted climax.

I don't know - Streets has become like a karaoke U2 song. Predictable and safe.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: Nielsen on September 11, 2009, 02:50:23 AM
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
Keep these setlist threads comin...

We need more.

It has become rather annoying - I share your pain  :-\
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: u2and on September 11, 2009, 05:17:27 AM
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
Wish I could vote for more than 1 song from this list for the poll

Me too, and I created it. I'd happily see all those songs go - it's not that they're bad songs (although I've never liked Pride), they just get really boring every time U2 play. And, if you go to more than one U2 show, you'll be very lucky to be surprised by anything on the set list.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: satellitedog01 on September 11, 2009, 06:49:54 AM
Yeah, U2 deserves critique. And Briscotheque, there are threads like these, cos some fans, including me, aren't satisfied with the current offering, that seems to go in the exact opposite direction that this tour offered and suggested.
These threads are, aside from shooting our mouths off,  also there to let anyone know, what people, who actually pay for U2's output, think of their efforts, and it seems that occasionally someone from the U2 staff takes a listen, and there have been changes that seemed to be in response to fans' opinions. So lets just keep on stating our disdain, if it leaves a chance to hear some more surprising stuff.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: very good on September 11, 2009, 08:15:05 AM
Interesting one this.

Playing stadiums means they HAVE to play the hits to a certain extent and part of what is special about seeing U2 live is the audience reaction to songs even if the setlists don't seem to vary enough.

My initial reaction to the setlist (before attending in Poland, Wembley and Sheffield) was generally very positive (starting with 4 newbies plus a host of other of my favourites) BUT I felt they had overdone the classics a bit (and in far too similar slots to the Vertigo tour).  However now I've experienced the tour first hand I've changed my mind.  Over the 3 shows I still haven't found and with or without you were (to my surprise) up there as THE highlights of the show!!  Streets is Streets so you can't drop ever, One is seminal so ditto.  Sunday Bloody Sunday and Pride could be alternated each night but, do you know what, I think the setlist is pretty damn perfect.  Agree with the NME about bringing in the Fly for the tepid City of Blinding Lights (but in the US they'll never drop City cos of the Obama thing) apart from that I can't see they need for much change.  Oh and bring back In a little while.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: u2and on September 11, 2009, 08:45:20 AM
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
Interesting one this.

Playing stadiums means they HAVE to play the hits to a certain extent and part of what is special about seeing U2 live is the audience reaction to songs even if the setlists don't seem to vary enough.

My initial reaction to the setlist (before attending in Poland, Wembley and Sheffield) was generally very positive (starting with 4 newbies plus a host of other of my favourites) BUT I felt they had overdone the classics a bit (and in far too similar slots to the Vertigo tour).  However now I've experienced the tour first hand I've changed my mind.  Over the 3 shows I still haven't found and with or without you were (to my surprise) up there as THE highlights of the show!!  Streets is Streets so you can't drop ever, One is seminal so ditto.  Sunday Bloody Sunday and Pride could be alternated each night but, do you know what, I think the setlist is pretty damn perfect.  Agree with the NME about bringing in the Fly for the tepid City of Blinding Lights (but in the US they'll never drop City cos of the Obama thing) apart from that I can't see they need for much change.  Oh and bring back In a little while.

I see what you mean - for my money it's the predictability of it all too. The same 'classics' tend to appear at the same times during a gig on every tour. I want to be inspired and surprised when I see a band. Anyway, I know what you mean about COBL - I can't stand the song (especially the ringing bell sound or whatever it is) so I'd happily be rocked hard by The Fly any day of the week above Streets, Pride etc...
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: markreed on September 11, 2009, 09:24:14 AM
In A Little While is back, its been played at several shows : not any for a few weeks mind you.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: Molson1020 on September 11, 2009, 09:45:01 AM
Please drop "Sunday Bloody Sunday" and replace it with either Discotehque or Mofo!

With that poppy "Crazy" remix, it's amazing and mind boggling they haven't played a Pop song after it!!!
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: MEMORY_MAN on September 11, 2009, 09:53:16 AM
I think most of those songs need to go.  I voted for With or Without You.  U2 has so many great songs that they could work on that are as good or better.  I think they forget what a great body of work they have that would be fitting with the new songs.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: joe73 on September 11, 2009, 10:28:54 AM
I voted for pride. It sounded tired at the 2 shows I attended. They don't have to drop it entirely but if it were played every 2nd show it might give it a bit more life. Look at new years day and angel of harlem, both were not regulars but were really fresh when they were played.

This is the only song I would drop. ISHFWILF was the biggest singalong of the shows and along with sunday bloody sunday hasn't sounded this good in years. Prior to seeing the shows the latter  song would have probably got my vote but the performances at both shows was very powerful.

The only change I would make would be to get rid of the steering wheel microphne during WOWY. This is a one song gimmick and whist it is fine for ultraviolet it doesn't work for the more intimimate mood of WOWY. Interestingly, at the last show I saw Bono switched to a normal mic. after the first verse and the song really came to life.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: u2and on September 11, 2009, 12:57:35 PM
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
I voted for pride. It sounded tired at the 2 shows I attended. They don't have to drop it entirely but if it were played every 2nd show it might give it a bit more life. Look at new years day and angel of harlem, both were not regulars but were really fresh when they were played.

This is the only song I would drop. ISHFWILF was the biggest singalong of the shows and along with sunday bloody sunday hasn't sounded this good in years. Prior to seeing the shows the latter  song would have probably got my vote but the performances at both shows was very powerful.

The only change I would make would be to get rid of the steering wheel microphne during WOWY. This is a one song gimmick and whist it is fine for ultraviolet it doesn't work for the more intimimate mood of WOWY. Interestingly, at the last show I saw Bono switched to a normal mic. after the first verse and the song really came to life.

You're right, ISHFWILF was a big sing along but that's probably because U2 haven't done it to death! And it always a pleasure to hear Ultraviolet but again, they haven't played that one to death either...

Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: Gravy11 on September 11, 2009, 07:12:27 PM
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
Seriously, who even thought about dropping Streets, don't tell me the show would be better with Streets out of the setlist, it would actually be a major hole in the set.  Like an interrupted climax.

"Interupted Climax" - LOFL!!! Awesome one!
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: aurabender on September 16, 2009, 06:31:05 PM
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
Please drop "Sunday Bloody Sunday" and replace it with either Discotehque or Mofo!

With that poppy "Crazy" remix, it's amazing and mind boggling they haven't played a Pop song after it!!!
yes!
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: Vervefloyd on September 16, 2009, 07:04:58 PM
for about 2 minutes I thought UTEOTW should not be played again this tour after listening to the 9/13 show.  Bono sounded as if he wanted to be doing anything but singing that song and then it seems edge kinda misplayed the beginning of the solo and Bono came to life with the Love, Love, Love section and brought the ending home very powerfully.

Add Magnificent to the poll.  That one is toast.  Listen to the 9/13 show and you will hear what I'm talking about.  Very WOWY-like performance from Bono.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: beau99 on September 17, 2009, 02:42:41 AM
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
I'm gonna go with Unforgettable Fire.  I know it wasn't played for a while before this tour, but that song has not aged well.  I'm actually kind of not really looking forward to it.
I'm just the opposite...

I've never seen U2 live before and this tour will mark my first show. TUF is one of my all-time favorites and was so happy to see they brought it back AND still manage to make it sound phenominal live. Hell, Bono sounds better singing it NOW then he did in 1984.
Title: Your Blue Room - Do we REALLY like it??
Post by: OptimaX on September 17, 2009, 05:42:35 AM
With the exception of Streets and One, I think they all have to go that are in the Poll, and the one that needs to go first; "I STILL haven't found what i'm looking for" Isn't even an option in the poll!  :-\

I mean, come'on people let's be honest here… Who of you people think he is actually going to find it after 23(!) years! I'm pretty sick of Bono keeping whining about it... I make a joke out of it now, but i'm serious... That song badly needs to go! It becomes Cheesy!

Right then... Your Blue Room. It is a very nice song. It is over ten years old and was never played live before. So.. U2 fans feel spoiled, happy, U2 fans want rare things to happen at their show. But is Your Blue Room really worth it? Drowning Man... Now that is another story, but YBR? Really? Have a look at the YouTube clips of it, it really isn't a 'great' moment in the show at all... Even the audiences don't really know what to do with it.
I think YBR is a bad move. Thanks for all the effort U2, we love it that you guys actually care about doing something 'special'. But I think Drowning Man would have been a much better Choice. Also, I can think of many songs that have been performed many times that would do much better. Gone, Kite, Please, Discotheque, The Fly, Even Better Than The Real Thing, Dirty Day, Lemon, If You Were That Velvet Dress, a full-band version (with the fantastic guitar solo at the end) of Ground Beneath Her Feet would have done amazingly better in this tour with this Claw-thing
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: DGordon1 on September 17, 2009, 05:43:14 AM
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
The only change I would make would be to get rid of the steering wheel microphne during WOWY. This is a one song gimmick and whist it is fine for ultraviolet it doesn't work for the more intimimate mood of WOWY. Interestingly, at the last show I saw Bono switched to a normal mic. after the first verse and the song really came to life.

I probably agree; the steering wheel works great during Ultraviolet. But I think it encourages Bono to be lazy with his vocal in WOWY.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: briscoetheque on September 17, 2009, 06:26:00 AM
Stuck in a Moment. And it actually WAS last night.

Stay away.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: jrnyc on September 30, 2009, 06:29:59 PM
With or Without You for sure, I was happy when it disappeared from some shows on the Vertigo tour. Also, New Years Day. There are other older songs they could play that havent been played in awhile.

Set list now is average at best, I like the new NLOTH songs, but they are too slow. They need to go deeper on older songs and mix up the encore also.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: mbeano on September 30, 2009, 11:48:49 PM
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
Ugh. I have no problem with Drowning Man, but I think it's be a dreadful closer, whereas MoS was MADE to be a closer...

AGREED
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: mbeano on September 30, 2009, 11:53:52 PM
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
Never drop Streets, but jeez, give the others a rest. This isn't a PBS special. It's a gig for people who avidly follow the band and some newbies. You don't have to reintroduce yourselves each night.

Disagree.  

In a 70,000 capacity stadium tour, I suspect the majority of the audience is made up of casual fans, by which I mean people who, yes are solid fans, but are not 'avidly' so, to use your word.  Many will have some albums, perhaps been to a concert or two in the past, are aquainted with the well known songs, which they may remember from 80's and 90's college parties, but they don't frequent fan forums discussing the relative merits of the tracklists of Zooropa and ATYCLB.  People who avidly follow the band, although a very large number in absolute terms, are likely to be in the minority.

Hence the well known tracks have to be included, to give the majority of causual fans (and a sizeable proportion of the minority of avid fans) what they want: an evening of classic U2, together with some new material.

I completely agree with your breakdown of what the audience makeup would be on a stadium tour.  I might even go so far as to say that the majority of the audience might not even own a full album outside of one of the greatest hits.  In arenas where the audience is around 15000 its a differnt story.
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: Joe G (Love You Like Mad Magazine) on September 30, 2009, 11:55:06 PM
"Streets" may be the one universal U2 song.  Even more than "One".

I voted for "Pride".
Title: Re: SPOILER - Poll - Songs to drop from the set list
Post by: Vervefloyd on October 01, 2009, 07:49:15 PM
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
Never drop Streets, but jeez, give the others a rest. This isn't a PBS special. It's a gig for people who avidly follow the band and some newbies. You don't have to reintroduce yourselves each night.

Disagree.  

In a 70,000 capacity stadium tour, I suspect the majority of the audience is made up of casual fans, by which I mean people who, yes are solid fans, but are not 'avidly' so, to use your word.  Many will have some albums, perhaps been to a concert or two in the past, are aquainted with the well known songs, which they may remember from 80's and 90's college parties, but they don't frequent fan forums discussing the relative merits of the tracklists of Zooropa and ATYCLB.  People who avidly follow the band, although a very large number in absolute terms, are likely to be in the minority.

Hence the well known tracks have to be included, to give the majority of causual fans (and a sizeable proportion of the minority of avid fans) what they want: an evening of classic U2, together with some new material.

I completely agree with your breakdown of what the audience makeup would be on a stadium tour.  I might even go so far as to say that the majority of the audience might not even own a full album outside of one of the greatest hits.  In arenas where the audience is around 15000 its a differnt story.

But nothing has to be played.  When a band feels they have to play a song, they are making a huge mistake.  Nothing sounds worse than a performance of a song that a band feels they have to play.